Bringing together the most insightful, opinionated and discursive opinion about schools on the internet
Richard Warren, a secondary school English teacher in the South West, writes:
Joe Nutt recently argued on this blog that teaching needs to become apolitical. The profession is in thrall, he suggests, to a cohort of ideologues. Teachers, he suggested, have crippled the state education system, holding it to ransom with their out-dated Marxist dreams. Without a ‘Damascene moment’, the profession will stagger from bad to worse; it is time, Mr Nutt believes, to remove politics from the classroom.
I don’t know about anyone else, but my school’s staffroom is strangely bereft of Marxist posters rallying us to join the rise of the workers. Instead, the walls sport data sheets about A*-C percentages, blown-up copies of the school’s behaviour management escalation ladder – and several posters for the Teacher Support telephone line. These seem to sum up teaching today; a demoralised and stressed workforce, quietly facing rising challenges in the classroom, while chasing targets imposed by those on high.
Are we ideologues ramming spurious political theories down our students’ throats? I don’t think so. I don’t know where we’d find the time.
Let’s get something straight. I’m a Leftie. I believe in good-quality, state-funded public services – and the taxes that are required to pay for these. I look with trepidation at an education secretary who is seemingly on a one-man mission to denigrate the state education system which he is meant to be nurturing; and I fear, in my most paranoid Leftie moments, that post-2015 there will be a wholesale move to privatise the entire state sector.
Yet I never let these fears come across in the classroom. I still cling to the ideal that teaching is a profession. I am, therefore, a professional. I turn up to work each day not, as might be suspected, in my sandals and knitted cardigan, but in my suit – in line with my school’s business ethos – and deliver the curriculum in the best way that I can. My personal politics have no place in my classroom.
I have worked with colleagues of all mainstream political hues – and never have I thought that any one of them might be trying to inculcate their classes to a particular political perspective. Joe Nutt’s call for teaching to become apolitical is designed to pander to the fears of the Right, who view teaching as a last bastion of Marxist nutters. This is simply not the case. It is a fear based on the ghosts of teachers past, bogeymen that right-wingers can scare themselves silly with.
The reality is that every good teacher knows that they are in a privileged position of trust. Inevitably there will be the occasional teacher who is a paid-up member of the BNP, or who revels in joining the anarchists during a G20 protest, but these are few and far between.
Every good teacher, regardless of their own political stance, understands that their role is not to create a cohort of acolytes, but instead to encourage students to think for themselves in preparation to become fully-functioning members of society.
And therein lies the rub. The problem we face today is not that teaching is too political, but the opposite. Teachers reflect the wider society from which they are drawn – and that is a society which is increasingly disengaged from the political system.
I have been brought to despair again and again when colleagues have proudly declared their intentions not to vote in local / European / general elections. I’ve found myself left incredulous when educated, independent, successful colleagues have declared themselves to have no truck with feminism. I’ve seen pupils who have expressed extreme racist or sexist views go unchallenged because their teacher is afraid of being seen as curtailing their freedom of speech.
I’m afraid that Joe Nutt and all those like him are desperately out of touch with the realities of the educational establishment. Unless we teachers re-engage with politics, how can we expect the students in our charge to want to do the same? It’s time for teachers to nail their green, grey, red, yellow or blue colours to the mast and stand up to be counted. We should not dictate to our students what to think – but we must show them that thinking is allowed.
Here, here.! I am also fearing the worst and see the gradual dismantling of the state education system happening before my disbelieving eyes. Free schools are the thin edge of the wedge , closely followed by schools being forced to become Academies. I am an un ashamed , old school `leftie`, educated in a massive comprehensive, working in a small independent school and a state school ,after 27 years working in state secondary schools. Many of my colleagues aged 55 plus are leaving the profession in droves, taking early retirement, as they can no longer stand the unremitting onslaught of `new` initiatives`, the denigration of our profession in the press and at a national level and the demoralised state of our staff rooms. I believe that Mr Gove is on a mission to de- professionalise teachers` status. Why else would Free school s be allowed to employ teachers without qualified teachers status and , yes ,even a Head teacher without teaching credentials. ? Similarly, we have the idea that ` top` graduates can pick up adequate teaching skills in a matter of months and then be parachuted in to poorly performing schools..Shame on the government and shame on our profession for allowing this to happen without protest.
Richard, I think you have missed the point of Mr Nutt's diatribe aganist the politicisation (sp?) of the teaching profession. I do not think that he was woried about the indoctination of little minds by lefty teachers, but rather they refusal of teachers to accept "reform" on what he sees as political grounds. We don't want payment by results because we are too political, we don't want an oppressive performance management system because we are too left wind, we want a decent pension and a reasonable chance of a retirement before we die because we are pinlo leftie liberals. Mr Nutt's patronising stance is that teachers should leave the political decisions to the political classes (I.E: Mr Nutt's friends) and simply accept what is decided without comment. He certainly would not support the view that "every action is a political action". Well, I'm not a leftie, but I think the time is coming when teachers will simply have had enough of their hard won work load agreement and remunaraiotn gains being systematically removed and will have to stand and fight, and I, for one, say, the sooner the better.
TES Editorial © 2013 TSL Education Ltd. All pages of the Website are
reproduce, duplicate, copy, sell, resell or exploit any material on the
Website for any commercial purposes. TSL Education Ltd Registered in England (No 02017289) at 26 Red Lion Square, London, WC1R 4HQ